Dehumanization in all quiet on the western front 2 essay

Letter to the Editor: I want to thank you for the great opportunity that "Somos Primos" provides for the preservation and advancement of Hispanic culture. The internet has provided humanity with a quantum leap in information and research. Therefore it is imperative that Hispanic culture in all its diversity be documented in cyberspace so that future generations may not only appreciate but understand their legacy.

Dehumanization in all quiet on the western front 2 essay

Anglian Exile 4, words Saving Private Ryan is widely acknowledged to be one of the best war films ever made. Released inthe film quickly became both a critical and commercial success, and was soon nominated for 11 Oscars — ultimately going on to win five including both Best Picture and Best Director.

In particular, the first half-an-hour of the film has received especial praise for its brutally intense portrayal of modern warfare — and was reckoned to be so realistic that many PTSD-prone veterans were advised not to go see it.

This is where it becomes useful to be a race realist. To be cursed with the gift of understanding is a heavy burden, but it also gives us an inimitable advantage over the normie film critic: War films are no exception.

They take you on an emotional journey. Think about their typical structure. Most think of All Quiet on the Western Front start off from a high point of idealism, then gradually move to a low point of cynicism and personal tragedy as the film progresses.

Our heroes, persuaded of the rightness of their cause and captivated by visions of personal glory, rush to enlist, only to come face-to-face with the grim reality of war.

The film sets up expectations of glory and heroism, only to subvert them over the course of the film. If Saving Private Ryan were genuinely an anti-war film, it would have followed a similar structure: Saving Private Ryan essentially does the opposite.

By having the most gruesome and realistic depictions of war at the beginning, Spielberg neatly turns the classic anti-war formula on its head. In most anti-war films, war is set up as good, only to be revealed as bad. In Saving Private Ryan the opposite happens: If the film had just been trying to show us the innate cruelty of war, it would have remained on the beach and dwelt upon the suffering of the wounded and dying — it would never have left the beach, because there would have been no more story to tell.

As I said, if the film wanted to emphasis the true horror of war, it would simply have remained on the beach. Instead, the camera quickly moves away and accompanies our heroes on a more traditional action-adventure narrative.

We see nothing beyond what they see, and have nothing else to base our conclusions on. Thus, when the film moves away from the beach, the carnage there quickly slips from our minds. Again, Spielberg is very selective in what he shows and what he leaves out of the frame — he keeps the camera on the carnage of the battlefield as long as is needed to invest us in the narrative, and no longer.

Customers who viewed this item also viewed

The point of the Omaha Beach scene is not just to get us to sympathize with their plight, it is to get us to subconsciously identify with their cause. Thus, when an American soldier falls, we feel the cathartic urge to take up the cause for which they died and continue the charge up the beach.

Dehumanization in all quiet on the western front 2 essay

The flipside of this subconscious connection with the plight and cause of the American soldier is a corresponding hatred for the faceless enemy who mercilessly guns him down. This leads us on to the second issue of framing: While the American soldiers are portrayed as courageous, heroic and self-sacrificial, the same is rarely true of their German counterparts.

Consider also the way in which soldiers on both sides die.

Dehumanization in all quiet on the western front 2 essay

While American soldiers die in terrible pain while pathetically calling for their mothers or desperately trying to pass on notes to their loved one i. But Spielberg allows us no such easy target.

The single-minded steadfastness of our protagonists who seem utterly convinced as to the morality of their cause leaves us just one outlet for our pent-up rage: Thus, the Germans become not people, but targets, to be gunned down like so many cardboard cutouts in a shooting gallery.

The scene with Private Jackson in the bell tower thus assumes a more sinister meaning. When he pulls the trigger, we are pulling it in our minds along with him.

After all, we have few moral qualms about seeing gunned down en masse in more traditional action flicks like Where Eagles Dare. However, the issue is, again, not merely the onscreen act of a German soldier being killed, but the way the act is framed.

In Saving Private Ryan, by the time we see German soldiers being killed, Spielberg has been careful to build up such a sense of emotional impetus that we need a form of catharsis. Thus, when a German soldier is killed, it is not simply an act within the film, it is an act internal to our own subconsciousness as well — it has an effect in the real world.

We harbor no particular animosity towards them — they are merely hapless goons who must be gunned down for the hero to reach his goal. They are merely plot points in action. Crudely put, their deaths mean nothing to us, because there is no negative emotion to release.

Consequently, they can have no external emotional effect on us. When we first meet Steamboat Willie, he is reduced to literally playing the fool as he disowns his leader and his country in an attempt to appease his captors. Spielberg is sure to bring the camera right in and revel in the pathetic pleading and humiliation of the German.Comments → Why Ben Shapiro Is A Total Fraud.

Ezekiel May 6, at am. Okay – a lot to take in, for someone who just recently started taking politics seriously, but damn.

This is an evisceration. Erich Maria Remarque’s All Quiet on the Western Front is an abstruse proclamation against war, which focuses especially on the destroying effects of war on soldiers’ humanity. Romantic ideals of warfare are under attack throughout Paul’s narration.

Somos Primos JULY , Online Issue Mimi Lozano © Dedicated to Hispanic Heritage and Diversity Issues Society of Hispanic Historical and Ancestral Research. All Quiet on the Western Front Speech This Essay All Quiet on the Western Front Speech and other 64,+ term papers, college essay examples and free essays are available now on Autor: haladj • April 15, • Essay • Words (4 Pages) • Views.

In All Quiet on the Western Front by Enrique Maria Remarque. the reader follows Paul Baumer as he fights through World War I and discovers the tests of being a soldier. As they survive through the war with each other. Paul and the other soldiers began to understand certain worlds of . All Quiet on the Western Front Essay Words | 4 Pages.

All Quiet on the Western Front The 19th century view of war expressed that it was the most honorable and glorious event that a man could participate in. This romantic viewpoint was quick to change after World War I.

Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex (Anime) - TV Tropes